MLB Managerial Changes and Team Narratives in 2024

As the 2024 Major League Baseball regular season nears its end, several managerial changes have highlighted the year's narrative of underperforming teams and unexpected challenges.

A Season of Managerial Shake-ups

The Chicago White Sox, Seattle Mariners, and Cincinnati Reds all opted for a change at the helm, with Pedro Grifol, Scott Servais, and David Bell, respectively, losing their managerial positions due to their teams’ underwhelming performances. The White Sox handed interim managerial duties to Grady Sizemore, though the transition has been anything but smooth, as reflected in an unfortunate 8-31 record thus far.

The Reds turned to Freddie Benavides to steer their ship, a necessary move given the fierce competition in their division. Meanwhile, the Mariners are still reeling from the dismissal of Scott Servais, whose tenure came to an abrupt end as the team’s playoff hopes dwindled.

Marlins' Strategic Decisions

In another notable move, the Miami Marlins declined to exercise the 2025 club option for their Manager Skip Schumaker in early April. Schumaker, the reigning National League Manager of the Year, finds himself in an uncertain position despite his recent accolades. The Marlins also saw the departure of their general manager, Kim Ng, signaling a potential shift in the organization’s strategic direction.

Challenges in Colorado

Bud Black, who has been at the helm of the Colorado Rockies for eight seasons, is facing the possibility of a second consecutive 100-loss season. Black’s overall record with the Rockies stands at 536 wins against 652 losses, a statistic that underscores the team’s prolonged struggle. The Rockies haven’t seen postseason action since 2018, a drought that has tested the patience of their fan base and management alike.

Toronto's Tumultuous Season

Up north, the Toronto Blue Jays have not met expectations under Manager John Schneider. The team finds itself languishing at the bottom of the AL East, leading to a pivot towards being deadline sellers. The Blue Jays' leadership must now brace for a period of rebuilding and reassessment in hopes of a brighter future.

Cardinals' Rebound and Stability

In contrast, the St. Louis Cardinals rebounded from their disastrous 91-loss campaign in 2023 to put together a winning season in 2024. This turnaround under the stewardship of Manager Oliver Marmol has been nothing short of impressive. The organization showed its confidence in Marmol by signing him to a contract extension through 2026 this past spring, solidifying his role for the foreseeable future.

Steady Hands in Los Angeles, New York, and Baltimore

Amidst the changes and upheavals, some franchises have opted for stability. Dave Roberts continues to manage the Los Angeles Dodgers effectively, while Aaron Boone remains in charge of the New York Yankees. Brandon Hyde retains his position with the Baltimore Orioles. These teams have chosen to stick with their current leadership, betting on experience and continuity to guide them through the ebbs and flows of the MLB season.

As the curtain falls on the 2024 regular season, the narrative is one of contrasts—a mix of calculated managerial changes aimed at revitalization and steadfast commitments to long-standing leaders. Each decision, whether born out of necessity or confidence, will shape the trajectory of these franchises in seasons to come. The final weeks promise to be a critical juncture for interim managers hoping to prove their mettle and for teams striving to chart a successful course forward.