As MLB's offseason progresses, the list of available free agents offers intriguing possibilities for teams looking to bolster their rosters. Among these free agents, Jack Flaherty remains a prime focus due to his potential impact on the mound. Flaherty, who recently concluded a season split between the Detroit Tigers and Los Angeles Dodgers, is currently evaluating short-term contracts that would provide him with high average annual salaries.
Flaherty's performance over the last three years has been a blend of highs and lows, reflected in his ERA+ scores of 93, 87, and 127. While these numbers showcase his variable form, they also hint at the ceiling of potential he could achieve if he returns to his best. Teams will have to weigh the risk and reward, considering his recent form and the promise evident in some of his outings.
Another top-ranked free agent is Anthony Santander, who stands at No. 15 on the list. Known for his offensive firepower, Santander faces reservations from clubs about his long-term value due to noted shortcomings in defense and baserunning. As Ken Rosenthal points out, "Unfortunately, Santander doesn't bring much more to the table than his bat: he's not a good defender or baserunner, meaning interested clubs will have to be confident that he can sustain his well-above-average offensive production well into his 30s."
While Santander and Flaherty captivate the free-agent narrative with their potential, several teams are considering the strategic signing of veteran relievers. Notably, the Yankees and Cubs have both shown considerable interest in lefty reliever Brooks Raley. At 36 years old, Raley's recent seasons have been marred by limited play due to Tommy John surgery, permitting him to make only eight appearances last season. However, his significant ERA+ of 153 since the beginning of the 2022 season speaks volumes about his effectiveness when fit.
In another strategic bid, the Atlanta Braves have strengthened their roster by signing former All-Star outfielder Garrett Cooper to a minor-league deal. As Cooper joins the Braves' camp, he brings with him a career batting line of .242/.297/.395 (86 OPS+) over his last 573 plate appearances. At 34, Cooper will aim to make an impact and potentially break back into the majors, providing depth and experience to a Braves squad eager to contend.
Each of these players reflects the dynamics and complexities of the current free-agency landscape. Flaherty, with his quest for a high-value short-term deal, represents the high-stakes gamble on untapped potential. Santander illustrates the balancing act teams face when offensive productivity outweighs other skills. Meanwhile, Raley and Cooper exhibit the insights teams are employing as they look to veteran leadership and potential comeback stories.
While clubs like the Yankees, Cubs, and Braves navigate these decisions, the offseason strategy hinges on identifying the players who best fit their organizational needs. The calculus involves not just evaluating statistical performance but assessing the long-term strategic vision, player health, and potential upside. As negotiations continue, these players remain pivotal in shaping team rosters heading into the next MLB season.